• About
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Editing
    • Pricing
    • Testimonials
    • Education and Affiliations
    • Résumé
    • Editing Links
  • Quilting
    • Feather Boot Camp
    • MQR
    • Meandering Magic
  • Embroidery
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

suzanne earley

You are here: Home / Blog / Book Reviews / 3 Star Reviews / “One Whole and Perfect Day” by Judith Clarke

July 9, 2015

“One Whole and Perfect Day” by Judith Clarke

One Whole and Perfect Day Book Cover One Whole and Perfect Day
Judith Clarke
Juvenile Fiction
Front Street Incorporated
2006
Hardcover
250
Purchased

In this Michael L. Printz Honor Book, Lily wishes she could be like the other girls in her class. But how can she? As the only sensible person in her family, she never has time to hang out with friends. Someone has to stay home to look after her brother. Maybe she should fall in love! What could be less sensible that that?
When her grandmother invites the whole family to a party, Lily cannot imagine how they will make it through the day. Her mother is always bringing home strange people. Lily doesn't even know her father . Her grandfather has disowned her brother. Her brother has a new girlfriend that no one has met. To top it all off, that day when her eye caught Daniel Steadman's just for a moment, she felt all woozy inside. If that was love, she isn't sure she likes the feeling. As the party approaches, all Lily can hope for is one whole and perfect day. Is it too much to ask?

I was completely underwhelmed by this novel and was glad it was so short. I didn’t really care about the characters, and all of the coincidences were a little too coincidental for me.

The whole thing felt a little pointless, and while I can handle a character-driven story that is light on plot, this was a little too far over that line for me.

Oooo, a three sentence post. OK, 4 with that one. Well, once I finish this it’ll be 6.

Related

Filed Under: 3 Star Reviews, Printz Project Tagged With: Printz Honor Book, Printz Project

Previous
Next

About Suzanne

When I'm not editing, I'm spending time with my family, cuddling with my pets, knitting, quilting, or reading. I'm also a part-time secretary for my local school district.

Hello

thanks for visiting

I'd love to hear what you think, please leave a comment!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Goodreads

Categories

Archives

  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Editing
  • Quilting
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
Instagram post 2197344641026691265_15732201 “Don’t blame your tools.” (I got my new carving tools yesterday and had to try them all out. This is my reminder that a good artist never blames her tools, but it sure is nice having really great tools. (I got Pfeil palm set C, plus one extra) #carvedecember #thepainteddiaries#suzanne_365
Instagram post 2196914898468997999_15732201 Can you find the cat in this picture?
Instagram post 2196566338359576256_15732201 My people wanted new socks for our upcoming ski trip, so I found some @darntoughvermont ski socks big enough for their giant feet! The XxL have padding on the shin, marks XL socks have padding in the top of the foot, too. (He wears a 14, my other people wear a size 16 shoe 🙃). I decided I needed a sock stamp. These socks are guaranteed for life! (Swipe to see the socks... bet you can’t guess which ones are mine, lol) #carvedecember #suzanne_365 #thepainteddiaries
Instagram post 2196129456853187803_15732201 Reputation is what other people know about you. Honor is what you know about yourself. —Lois McMaster Bujold, my absolute favorite author, has been named a SFEA Grand Master. This is from her book A Civil Campaign.  I think about this concept a lot. For my #carvedecember carving, I meant the rays to be shallower, but I slipped. I’m also terrible at lining them up. #thepainteddiaries#suzanne_365
Instagram post 2195863854498559253_15732201 The prompt was tea time, but I don’t do tea or coffee, so hot cocoa it was! I found this mug shortly after signing up for @everythingartuk’s Wanderlust 2020. While drinking and reading, I felt like I was being watched. I think he thought I had ice cream in my mug and was waiting for his turn. #kasiasadventcalendar #suzannesadventjournal #suzannegetsmessy#getmessyartjournal #dailyhobbes
Instagram post 2195281820554277242_15732201 White on white. I did some journaling with a clear Glaze pen on the predecorated page. The words are modeling paste through a stencil. My intention was to do some more layering after it was dry, but I kinda like it like this, so I’m going to leave it for now! #kasiasadventcalendar #suzannesadventjournal #thelayeredpage #suzannegetsmessy #getmessyartjournal

Copyright © 2019 · suzanne earley · Hello You Designs